Podcrushed

Podcrushed — the podcast where Penn Badgley reads your middle school story -- explores the heartbreak, anxiety and self-discovery of being a teenager. Hosts Penn Badgley, Nava Kavelin, and Sophie Ansari bring you stories and conversations about middle school - from childhood crushes, to battles with body hair, to schoolyard scuffles. The results are sometimes awkward, sometimes heartwarming, and always relatable. Sales and Distribution by Lemonada Media https://lemonadamedia.com/

Website

Every guest on Podcrushed

129 guests, ranked by how many people never want them back.

1. —
   Kevin Smith

   Kevin Smith · Jun 2025

   0 votes

   Never again
2. —
   Madison Beer

   Madison Beer · Jan 2026

   0 votes

   Never again
3. —
   Noah Centineo

   Noah Centineo · Jan 2025

   0 votes

   Never again
4. —
   Paul Wesley

   Paul Wesley · Sep 2025

   0 votes

   Never again
5. —
   Shay Mitchell

   Shay Mitchell · Jul 2022

   0 votes

   Never again
6. —
   Taylor Momsen

   [Rerun] Taylor Momsen · 2 episodes

   0 votes

   Never again
7. —
   Alyson Stoner

   Alyson Stoner · Aug 2025

   0 votes

   Never again
8. —
   Conan O'Brien

   [Rerun] Conan O'Brien · 3 episodes

   0 votes

   Never again
9. —
   Andy Grammer

   Andy Grammer · Nov 2022

   0 votes

   Never again
10. —
    Bryce Dallas Howard

    Bryce Dallas Howard · Jun 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
11. —
    Candice King

    Candice King · Jun 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
12. —
    Elizabeth Lail

    [Rerun] Elizabeth Lail · 2 episodes

    0 votes

    Never again
13. —
    Joe Manganiello

    Joe Manganiello · Jul 2024

    0 votes

    Never again
14. —
    Karen Gillan

    Karen Gillan · Jun 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
15. —
    Nina Dobrev

    [Rerun] Nina Dobrev · 2 episodes

    0 votes

    Never again
16. —
    Sera Gamble

    Goodbye YOU: A Farewell to Sera Gamble · May 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
17. —
    Sophie Thatcher

    Sophie Thatcher · Mar 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
18. —
    Amber Midthunder

    Amber Midthunder · Mar 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
19. —
    Ambyr Childers

    Ambyr Childers · Sep 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
20. —
    Anna Camp

    Anna Camp · May 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
21. —
    Anna Martin

    92NY Presents: Podcrushed LIVE (with Modern Love’s Anna Martin) · Jul 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
22. —
    Blakely Thornton

    Blakely Thornton · Jan 2026

    0 votes

    Never again
23. —
    Brian Baumgartner

    Brian Baumgartner · Dec 2022

    0 votes

    Never again
24. —
    Brianne Howey

    Brianne Howey · Mar 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
25. —
    Caleb McLaughlin

    Caleb McLaughlin · Dec 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
26. —
    Charlotte Ritchie

    Charlotte Ritchie · Dec 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
27. —
    Chase Stokes

    Chase Stokes · Oct 2024

    0 votes

    Never again
28. —
    Domino Kirke-Badgley

    Domino Kirke-Badgley · Oct 2022

    0 votes

    Never again
29. —
    Dylan Arnold

    Dylan Arnold · Aug 2024

    0 votes

    Never again
30. —
    Ed Speleers

    Ed Speleers · Mar 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
31. —
    James Morosini

    James Morosini · Oct 2024

    0 votes

    Never again
32. —
    James Scully

    James Scully · Oct 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
33. —
    Jay Ellis

    Jay Ellis · Aug 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
34. —
    Jenny Han

    Jenny Han · Jul 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
35. —
    Jesse Metcalfe

    Jesse Metcalfe · Feb 2026

    0 votes

    Never again
36. —
    Jharrel Jerome

    Jharrel Jerome · Mar 2023

    0 votes

    Never again
37. —
    Lee Toland Krieger

    YOU Finale Rewatch (with Lee Toland Krieger), pt 2 · 4 episodes

    0 votes

    Never again
38. —
    Leighton Meester

    Leighton Meester Returns (Series Finale) · 3 episodes

    0 votes

    Never again
39. —
    Lola Kirke

    Lola Kirke · Dec 2025

    0 votes

    Never again
40. —
    Lucas Bravo

    Lucas Bravo · Oct 2024

    0 votes

    Never again